All posts tagged protests

On Twitter in Iran

An MIT graduate student I know wrote the following about the Iranian post-election protests, after I asked what he thought of the use of technology there. Money quote:

The crux, I think, is this: twitter et. al. provide more interesting and useful communication tools.  But communication isn’t enough, you have to wield power, and power doesn’t happen on the Internet… Communication is still really important to enable action.  But that communication doesn’t have to be new or fancy, and it may work better if it isn’t.

So what’s next in digital activism technology?  There’s a great quote in this Time article: “The sky is falling, but here we are — millions of us — sitting around trying to invent new ways to talk to one another.”  I think there’s something to that, and I think there’s something of a distraction and time sink that the Internet brings to efforts to enact meaningful social change.  I think we might be better served learning about what to say to one another than what incremental improvements we can make to the medium.  Learning how to influence people and change their minds, get them to be more aware of the plight of everyone else.  My personal research goals are around finding out how to get technologists to listen more deeply to communities in need about what their problems are, rather than what seems cool or exciting or technically challenging to the technologist.

Full email after the cut.

Continue reading →

The cost of Iraq

Opportunity cost of the Iraq War

I’ve been agnostic about the Iraq occupation for the past couple years, due to the following uncertainty: we shouldn’t have gone in, but now that we have, is an immediate pullout really in everybody’s best interest? Mother Jones magazine raised this question recently in a feature called U.S. Out Now! How? The editors sum up the dilemma in the following way:

For those of us who argued against invading, it is tempting to simply demand an end to “Bush’s War” and wash our hands of it. But as General Anthony Zinni, former head of U.S. forces in the Middle East, told us, “Your conscience is not clean just because you’re a peace demonstrator.” In other words, just because you weren’t in favor of going in doesn’t mean you’re not responsible for what happens when we pull out.

I have a feeling that we’re doing more harm than good, and that the violence would drop if we left. But honestly, I just don’t know enough about what’s going on there.

One thing I do feel strongly about however, is that we need to keep in mind not just the facts on the ground, but how mind-blowingly expensive this war is. Continue reading →